Page 1 of 3
Believe my clutch basket is wasted ROUND2 - need help
Posted: 10:42 pm Feb 21 2011
by turtle
My clutch basket has some deep grooves in it, a good millimeter or more. I think the basket is beyond filing, but I don't know for sure so I'm looking for opinions. Is it worth salvaging? If it is toast, is there anywhere else to get a basket besides Fredette or OEM?
Also, on the hub nut, I searched and have some ideas for holding the basket while loosening the nut, but what's the best way?
Finally, is applying increasing torque (with a pipe on a breaker bar if needed) the way to go to loosen the hub nut, or is hitting the breaker with a hammer the better idea to break it loose?
I have posted this before but I own a Kawaski Concours street bike and there is a great forum for that bike. You can learn anything and everyting about the Concours there. I never expected to find the same thing when I bought my KDX but I think I have. Y'all rock

and I appreciate the help while I am learning my way around the KDX. Thanks!

Posted: 10:45 pm Feb 21 2011
by Slick_Nick
Hit the nut with an impact wrench, or do the penny trick in the gears.
Posted: 11:14 pm Feb 21 2011
by SS109
Impact wrench. Takes about 5 seconds with the cheap electric Harbor Freight one I have.
I don't know of anyone other than Fredette and OEM. Sorry.
Posted: 12:04 am Feb 22 2011
by frankenschwinn


SS109 wrote:Impact wrench. Takes about 5 seconds with the cheap electric Harbor Freight one I have.
I don't know of anyone other than Fredette and OEM. Sorry.
+1
Posted: 01:31 am Feb 22 2011
by Mr. Wibbens
If it was me I'd file it
Actually I'd use my Dremel
Posted: 03:01 am Feb 22 2011
by Rick
You can remove the plates, and file it in posistion if need be. Just shove some rags in the case to catch the shavings. It will take more time though, and you have to be real carefull that the shavings dont go in the case. Add new oil when done, ride it for a few minutes. Change the oil again. Check for metal in the oil. Should be good to go.
Posted: 07:30 am Feb 22 2011
by KarlP
I'D file that basket without hesitation.
I would pull that pushrod in the center of the clutch and make sure you have the shim that goes under it if there is one. Put 'em away safely, they are easily lost in the shuffle.
I've been using XR400 friction plates.
Posted: 08:25 am Feb 22 2011
by gregp
I have filed plenty of baskets in my day, and that is a good candidate for that practice - however, you should be aware that filing the basket will accelerate the wear at that spot, and the basket will soon be gooved again - much quicker than those originally appeared. I suspect this is because the plates have more room to slap back and forth...
Posted: 08:35 am Feb 22 2011
by turtle


gregp wrote:I have filed plenty of baskets in my day, and that is a good candidate for that practice - however, you should be aware that filing the basket will accelerate the wear at that spot, and the basket will soon be gooved again - much quicker than those originally appeared. I suspect this is because the plates have more room to slap back and forth...
Hmm ... makes sense. How soon is soon? I'd rather stay out of there for a while once it's done.
Is the FRP basket any more durable than the stocker?
Posted: 08:47 am Feb 22 2011
by Coop
Any deeper than .020" and it needs replaced in my opinion.
Posted: 08:55 am Feb 22 2011
by David_L6
I'd replace that basket.
Posted: 09:11 am Feb 22 2011
by Slick_Nick
The FRP basket is more durable. I don't think it would ever groove.
Posted: 10:38 am Feb 22 2011
by Mr. Wibbens
Mine was grooved like that back in '03
I carefully removed the largest grooves with my dremel then filed it square
It still looks great today
Posted: 10:41 am Feb 22 2011
by Slick_Nick


Mr. Wibbens wrote:Mine was grooved like that back in '03
I carefully removed the largest grooves with my dremel then filed it square
It still looks great today
I know you LOVE to reuse old parts, but cmon that's just ridiculous....
Posted: 10:44 am Feb 22 2011
by Coop
Slick_Nick wrote:
I know you LOVE to reuse old parts, but cmon that's just ridiculous....
LOL I knew that was coming...

Posted: 11:05 am Feb 22 2011
by scheckaet
I don't see the point in trashing something that could still give you another year of use (maybe more, maybe less).
What do you have to lose? it shouldn't take too long to remove the clutch, file that smooth and go ride.
There is an article on thumpertalk about filing the clutch basket in the how to section.
I'd get the new basket as a back up when money is available, but that's just me.
Posted: 11:07 am Feb 22 2011
by scheckaet
Posted: 11:10 am Feb 22 2011
by Mr. Wibbens
it's nothing compared to your krusty old bearings
Posted: 12:11 pm Feb 22 2011
by Slick_Nick


Mr. Wibbens wrote:it's nothing compared to your krusty old bearings
Krusty is the new clean! I was just ahead of the trend! ;)
Posted: 12:44 pm Feb 22 2011
by Varmint
Possibly stupid question but I need to ask so I can learn.
Where is the damage I'm looking for here? Is is the four grooves in the basket where the plate tabs have carved themselves in?
What problem does this cause? Plates do not seperate easily?
Your solution is to file these grooves away. Does this make the opening bigger allowing for slop in the plates?
Thanks!